(RESOLVED – as far as Relation & Brand goes) Vistaprint: spamming outdated and erroneous personal addresses
One of the many parties who spam the ten year old boxes are Vistaprint, whom I have discussed here before. The ESP is Relation & Brand, a Swedish operator.
It’s not the first time Vistaprint have spammed through Relation & Brand (my notes on that count go back to October 2010), but it may be the first time I’ve spotted them doing it during the existence of the Mainsleaze blog. Now what’s really surprising is that I have an email confirmation from the CEO of Relation & Brand dated October 25, 2011 that says they’ve closed the account of Vistaprint.
It turns out that there are a handful of business registrations in the Finnish Business Information System where the contact e-mail address is amongst my recent collection of ancient spamtraps. You’d think business owners would specify a new email that works once the old one died. You’d think business owners would notice the old one died. Not all did, so a few of our new traps get “legitimate” and fresh (as in, “B2B addresses freshly harvested from the BIS” kind of fresh) spam. Some of these businesses are sole individuals trading (“private persons carrying on trade” in the BIS parlance) and some of these email addresses clearly belong to natural persons (as in “firstname.lastname@domain.example” rather than “sales@business.domain.example”). So, whoever spams them is not just spamming, but illegally processing outdated and erroneous personal data as well.
Spamming IP: 213.174.90.233, 213.174.90.234, 213.174.90.235, 213.180.95.188
Spam headers:
Return-Path: <bounce_X@clickredirect.com> Received: from mail-10.relationbrand.com (mail-10.relationbrand.com [213.180.95.188]) by x (Postfix) with ESMTP id x for <x>; Tue, 14 Feb 2012 17:2x:xx +0200 (EET) Received: from jEDMailer (mail-3x.relationbrand.com [195.178.171.156]) by mail-10.relationbrand.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id x for <tx>; Tue, 14 Feb 2012 16:2x:xx +0100 (CET) From: "Vistaprint" <professionalprinting@vistaprint.com> To: <x> Reply-To: "Vistaprint" <noreply.vistaprint@edirectweb.se> Subject: X, saat 250 käyntikorttia + bonuksen - ilman sitoumuksia MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="----=_moc.dnarbnoitaler.www" Message-Id: <20120214152133.60C2A795615@mail-10.relationbrand.com> Date: Tue, 14 Feb 2012 16:21:33 +0100 (CET)
Human-readable spam content: The text/plain part only has the opt-out and data controller information.
Jos viesti ei näy kunnolla, klikkaa täst
http://www.clickredirect.com/lr3.asp?mKey=x&cKey=x&mail=xTietosi salataan SSL 128bit -salauksella.
Osoitelähde: Euro Contact Pool SE 11970 StockholmHaluan poistaa osoitteeni Vistaprintin postituslistalta.
http://www.clickredirect.com/u.asp?yKey=x&email=x&rURL=http://e2.relationbrand.com/par_k88/_unsubscribe-default/mail.html
Keltainen Pörssi have gone Vistaprint too.
Return-Path: <a_b_c_d@bounce.isteer.net>
Received: from bounce.isteer.net (bounce.isteer.net [77.73.6.98])
by x (Postfix) with ESMTP id x
for <x>; Tue, 21 Feb 2012 07:1x:xx +0200 (EET)
Received: from bounce.isteer.net (localhost [127.0.0.1])
by bounce.isteer.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id x
for <x>; Tue, 21 Feb 2012 07:0x:xx +0200 (EET)
Date: Tue, 21 Feb 2012 07:0x:xx +0200 (EET)
From: Keltainen pörssi
To: x
Message-ID: <a.b.c.JavaMail.tomcat@bounce.isteer.net>
Subject: 250 käyntikorttia + kotelo + leimasin vain sinulle - ilman velvoitteita
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/alternative;
boundary="----=_Part_a_b.c"
Content-Length: 19221
Lines: 145
A particular point of interest is that it’s technically impossible for a spamtrap to unsubscribe from Keltainen Pörssi mailing lists. The links to unsubscribe don’t contain the identifying information, and it’s necessary to login to unsubscribe. The spamtraps didn’t come with knowledge of the necessary information. I don’t think this is in accordance with the Act on the Protection of Privacy in Electronic Communications, whose Sections 26 and 27 require that recipients be able easily and at no charge to prohibit further direct marketing.
We very much appologize for this sendout, since we closed down this account last year after lots of complaints from recipients of Vistaprint. As a very unwelcomed surprize, a new sendout was performed through our servers last week by another partner who is reselling our ESP service in their name. We immediately contacted our partner and had them terminate this client (it ofcause resulted in lots of spam and abuse management for us).
Vistaprint seems to have gone through all Swedish ESPs and when stopped at first line went further through resellers of ESP services. We very much regret that we did not have a better control of our resellers clients, and will distribute our inofficial client blacklist to all partners in order to stop those send outs in our network. We do not tolerate any kind of spam or spam-alike sendouts, it does not contribute anything to anybody and definitely nothing for us as an ESP.
Best regards and my deepest apologies
Nichlas Spångberg
CEO
Relation & Brand AB
St Eriksgatan 117
S-113 43 Stockholm
Sweden
nichlas@relationbrand.com
Thank you very much, Nichlas, for stopping by and explaining what had happened. It is truly appreciated.